Why so strange?

Text Peter Spence Photographs Various

 

As we continue our discussions on the birds we find in Kloof, we have learned quite a lot about their food, what they feed on and who feeds on them, and the strategies they adopt to survive.

We have learned that simply identifying birds soon develops into a hunger to know more. That has certainly been the case for me.

In this article we will be looking mostly at waterbirds – birds that make their livelihood in and around water – and will pick up on some unusual features and anomalies.

Grabbers and stabbers

For example, fish-eating birds can be divided into 2 groups, the ‘Grabbers’ and the ‘Stabbers’. They may live in the same habitat and look much the same – but have a look at the bill of the Reed Cormorant. It has a distinct hook at the end, a definite ‘Grabber’. The Darter, on the other hand, looks very similar except that it has a long, pointed, dagger for a bill with which the same fish could be speared – definitely a ‘Stabber’.

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Reed Cormorant

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

African Darter

Photo: Dave Rimmer

There are of course other identifying features which separate the species, for instance the neck thickness of the Cormorant is greater than that of the Darter. However, taking another look at the same 2 birds, you may be able to see that there is a difference in the webbing of their feet. They both have webbed feet, but the Cormorant has webbing spread between all 4 toes and the Darter over only 3 toes giving it a free ‘thumb’. You may see it better with these photos of the White-breasted Cormorant (another ‘grabber’) and the Darter (another ‘stabber’).

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

White-breasted Cormorant

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

African Darter

Photo: John Oliver

So feet are another differentiator.

Foot structures

We expect water birds to have webbed feet, or at least those that paddle around in dams and ponds. Well, it appears that there are 4 types of foot structure for water birds:

1) Arisodactyl – the commonest form – no webbing – ideal for lily-walking.

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Common Moorhen

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Black Crake

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

African Jacana

Photo: David Allan

2) Webbed – for ducks – webbing spread between 3 toes. The 4th toe is free, much like a thumb.

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Spur-winged Goose

Photo: Dave Rimmer

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

White-faced Duck

Photo: Dave Rimmer

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Yellow-billed Duck

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

African Black Duck

Photo: Dave Rimmer

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

African Darter

Photo: David Allan

3) Totipalmate – for Cormorants and Pelicans – webbing spread between all 4 toes. There is no free ‘thumb’.

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Pink-backed Pelican

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Pink-backed Pelican

Photo: David Allan

4) Lobed – for Grebes, Coots and Finfoots – Instead of webbing the toes are ‘squashed’ lengthwise to create a flange effect.

Grebes and coots are excellent swimmers, both on and under the surface of the water, so the lobed alternative to webbed feet seems to work well.

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Red-knobbed Coot lobed foot

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Photo: Red-knobbed Coot on land

Photo: Dave Rimmer

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Red-knobbed Coot swimming

Photo: David Allan

Finding photos of Little Grebes showing their lobed feet was always going to be a problem, but miraculously Dave Rimmer had this photo of himself with Paul Bartho untangling a Little Grebe caught in a nylon fishing line!

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Little Grebe swimming

Photo: Dave Rimmer

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Little Grebe in nylon tangle

Photo: Dave Rimmer

*The Finfoot has not been reported in the Kloof area, but 14 sightings have been recorded at the nearby Inanda Dam. It has been included due to its curious lobed foot structure as well as its proximity to our area.

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

African Finfoot

Photo: Dave Rimmer

I have created a table below which compares the foot structures of the various Kloof waterbirds.

Foot structures of various Kloof waterbirds

Arisodactyl

  • Common Moorhen
  • Black Crake
  • African Jacana

Webbed

  • Egyptian Goose
  • White-faced Whistling Duck
  • Spur-winged Goose
  • Yellow-billed Duck
  • African Darter
  • African Black Duck

Totipalmate

  • Reed Cormorant
  • White-breasted Cormorant
  • Pink-backed Pelican

Lobed

  • Red-knobbed Coot
  • Little Grebe
  • African Finfoot*

Sketches adapted from Roberts Birds of Southern Africa VII Edition.

Note that the Coot, which often shares the same habitat amongst the reeds of small dams with the similarly sized Common Moorhen, even sounding alike, has lobed feet rather than open feet. Curious.

Territorial threats

We regularly do our birding in the Iphithi Nature Reserve in Kloof, where there is normally a resident pair of Egyptian Geese. When all is calm and peaceful the pair look, well, normal, but as soon as another pair comes flying past there is a lot of cackling and honking.

What is most extraordinary is the aggressive attitude taken by the resident male. Apart from the noise he makes, he also shows off his upper wing coverts, flashing a warning signal – a bright white ‘flag’ appears on his side – presumably to show the intruder how fierce and big he is. Have a look yourself some time.

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Egyptian Goose in relaxed mode

Photo: David Allan

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Egyptian Goose in defensive mode

Photo: David Allan

Sense of taste

In our last article, headed What’s the bill, we referred to the role the bill plays in identifying birds in the field. There are also other interesting things to be found amongst the bills. Two of the more prominent bill owners in our area are the Trumpeter Hornbill and the Hadeda Ibis.

Trumpeter Hornbill

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Trumpeter Hornbill

Photo: David Allan

The bill is not just a thing of beauty (to the beholder) and it obviously serves as a resonating chamber for its heartfelt cry which can be heard echoing over the forests, it’s favoured habitat. The casque is also useful for parting vegetation as it searches for fruit in the leafy tops of the forest. But much of this you could work out for yourself.

But there is another usefulness in that bill – it also houses a large tongue which it uses to get a good sense of taste of what it is eating.

The casque is extremely light weight and is not a burden to the long-suffering bird after all.

Hadeda Ibis

Hadeda Ibis, photo by Warwick Tarboton

Hadeda Ibis

Photo: David Allan

We have featured the Hadeda a number of times in our articles, even though it is not a popular bird. However, it does have a number of talents which might take you by surprise.

That splendid bill is not just a thing of beauty (again, to the beholder) but it also houses a groove of live cells which reach all the way down to the tip. It is soft, pliable and grooved which feeds back information on both taste and smell. This enables it to judge whether the object it has found, as it pushes down into the soil, is edible or not.

Why so strange? Because strange ideas do sometimes work, it seems.

Cape White-eye, photo by Warwick Tarboton

About the author

Peter was born and raised in the sub-tropical haven of the then Lourenço Marques, now Maputo but was schooled in KZN. With a Mechanical Engineering degree from Cambridge he focused on his engineering career until moving to Durban in the mid 70’s and immediately developed an interest in birds. He has travelled extensively throughout southern Africa on birding holidays which helped him reach his target of 700 bird sightings. More recently he has turned his focus to bird atlasing and is a valuable contributor to the Southern African Bird Atlas Project. He is also a one of the organisers of the Krantzkloof Bird Club.